Home Comic Reviews Comic News Columns Comic Sites Interviews About
 

 

1








Arrowsmith: 
              So Smart in their Fine Uniforms<

Arrowsmith: So Smart in their Fine Uniforms
[Reprints 1-6 of the mini series]
AUG/2004

Publisher: Wildstorm
Writer: Kurt Busiek
Pencils: Carlos Pacheco
Inks: Jesus Merino
Colors: Alex Sinclair
Letters: Comicraft
Price: $14.95 US/R169.00 SA



From the men who brought us amazing runs on major superhero teams such as The Avengers, JLA and JSA comes a different kind of tale. Kurt Busiek and Carlos Pacheco tell the story of one man against the world...at war!

Fletcher Arrowsmith lives in a world where magic mixes with the mundane and where dragons and men fight side by side in the trenches. It’s 1915 and World War One [WWI] rages throughout Europe. Fletcher has decided to sign up to become an Airman, an elite group of soldiers/wizards that battle the enemy from the skies. What starts off as a heroic adventure ends very differently in the blood-stained mud of Europe’s battlefields.

I was looking for something to read the other day and this trade paperback [a collection of single issues or an entire mini-series collected in a graphic novel format] caught my eye. Due to its amazing visual style and original viewpoint of the topic of war I snapped it up. After finishing reading it I was blown away. The idea of mixing magic, fantasy creatures and a WWI era setting just seemed like a campy and somewhat forced idea when I first heard of this series. Now that I’ve read it I don’t know how to start explaining to you just how well it’s been thought out and brought across.

Kurt Busiek [JLA/Avengers, Avenger Forever] is a stickler for detail and Arrowsmith’s world is perfectly thought out to the N-th degree. From the way magic is used in the war to the nuances of the day and age, it all works seamlessly together to forge one of the best ‘new’ comic universes that I have seen in a long time. With enduring characters and great imagination shown by both writer and artist this book stands out as a highly original work in a genre in which I thought we had pretty much seen it all.

You can expect to see Mages inventing cruel and amazing weapons of mass destruction. Rock Trolls and Vampires are used as special units in the army and men fly through the skies of Europe instead of biplanes. All of the above ideas are beautifully realized and Busiek implements them in a marvelously subtle and suitable way in order for them to not come across as campy or ‘B Grade Movie’ in style.

Once you’ve read through this whole book you will soon realize that what started out as a splendidly magical tale of ‘Harry Potter meets WWI’ has turned into a vital commentary on war and its place in the world yesterday, today and tomorrow. Busiek weaves in a social commentary on the effects of war and how pointless and manipulative it is of its soldiers. This is a critical look at war and the effects that atrocities/war crimes have through the ranks from high command right down to the common soldier who has to implement these horrific undertakings. The futility of war is also raised, how it’s a game of ‘fight and fight back’ and how no one is in charge of a war but rather it lays charge over us. I was actually quite amazed at how Busiek managed to weave such hard hitting ideas into such a ‘far out’ war story and still get it to work without it coming across as feeling forced and false.

Via his closing scene Busiek writes a letter to the world around him asking for peace and an end to war and the final pages are a testament to this theme. For all the vibrant ideas and the fresh sights and sounds of this fantastic and magical new world, at its core this comic is a commentary and reflection on the horror of war.

The artwork by Carlos Pacheco [Superman/Batman, Avengers Forever] is a perfect fit for this story as he manages to envision Busiek’s masterful and magical ideas and seamlessly blend them into an early 1900’s European setting. Pacheco excels at drawing some awesome European architecture as he renders Paris, Germany and a host of foreign locales. These towns and cities come complete with painstakingly detailed Churches, courtyards and fountain squares of yesteryear. The costumes and character design are second to none and have the ‘big production’ feel of a Lord of The Rings scale film. With great character design for not only Fletcher and his fellow Airmen but also ‘Rocky’ the Rock Troll, Hilda and the rest of the Dragonets and a bunch more original and heartwarming characters. I am reminded of the kind of imagination and scope that we see in many of Miyazakis [Spirited Away, Princess Mononoke] films. The visual style of this book is bright, fresh and positive and at the same time has a magical quality thanks to the great imagination of Mr. Pacheco, a job well done.

The use of the bright colour palette by Alex Sinclair [Superman, Batman: Hush] keeps an essentially sad and depressing tale positive. Sinclair uses lighting effects perfectly as he subtly changes hair colour and skin tone as characters enter into the shadows or have a different light source cast on them.

The lettering and graphic design of this collection help to round off a great overall artistic impression. The cover and interior graphic design sold me on this book, complete with spot varnishes, introduction pages, sketches and great font choices this is a gorgeous collection to behold, hats off to all involved.

A must read for any fantasy or war genre fans. A book that will amaze you and make you think at the same time, a true modern comic work of genius.

Score 10/10
Reviewed By:Iain Duncan


All characters, their likenesses, and their related titles and logos are ™ and © of their respective owners unless otherwise noted.
All reviews are property of Southside 2003, if you wish to use any content on this site please email us.